Signature 01

Positive.
+  While simple, it's very elegant. The light overlayed texture adds depth to the image, as well as the subtle swirls in the background.
+ I loved this one in particular because it was very simple, yet very elegant to me! The text is absolutely perfect to where you can see it, but it doesn't draw your attention away from the entire signature itself.
+ I love the picture of Haruka that was used. The shadow of the image added to it looked really cool. I loved how the text and the words fit perfectly into the image.
+ It has an interesting double effect and nice use of brushes and/or textures. The text is simple but well placed and the overall coloring it's nice.
Negative.
Best Resources.
* Simple but well done. The birds brushes were my favorite.
* I love the faded image of Haruka in the background, the bird silhouettes, and the smoky looking texture. The whole thing is very well put together and not too overpowering.

Signature 02

Positive.
+ I love the close-up of Venus and Mars and the little heart accent between them, it's lovely framing for a couple banner.
Negative.
- A bit too simple for my tastes. It's not bad, but it doesn't say much thing to me.
Best Resources.

Signature 03

Positive.
+ I love the rain effect and the strong colors. The font choice is also super nice.
Negative.
- I couldn't really make out what the text said. :/ It was very light it practically blended in.
- The font is very jarring and doesn't suit the feeling of the image. The light spots would possibly look better if they were less bright.
Best Resources.

Signature 04

Positive.
+ Loved the use of "rain" effect, font used goes well with the picture that was used; quote really sums up the scene perfectly (i.e. "Soldiers of Justice" are all Sailor Senshi).
+ It's bright and crisp with out bring obnoxious. The cropping is nicely done and the font is lovely.
+ I enjoyed the effect used in this signature in particular ^^
Negative.
- I think the animation effect takes away from the artwork in the signature. It makes it look overcrowded and overdone.
Best Resources.
* (again XD) - Loved this one the best! User took a simple image, added a very cool rain effect with a simple-yet-elegant font on the top and a more basic font underneath; which are both very easy to read. Font colors match the image used very well. Picture is very well-lit, not overly bright so you can see each character just fine without being blinded.
* The rain was a surprising thing to add, but it really fitted the image feel.
* I really liked the picture and then all of the things that were added made it look so great! I loved text and the rain.

Signature 05

Positive.
Negative.
- Font used is in all capitals and is very distracting, a little difficult to understand what it's saying. Too much lighting used overall.
- The lighting makes the colors in the signature look faded and not as bright as they could be. The text also takes away from the nice cropping of the signature and blocks a whole portion of what the signature is actually about.
Best Resources.

Signature 06

Positive.
+ Interesting cropping and I love the font type. Everything also works perfectly well color and composition-wise.
Negative.
Best Resources.
* I love the texture - the colors really compliment the original graphic's.

Signature 07

Positive.
+ It's simple but pretty. I like the use of lighting and the cropping. Also the text is not overpowering and balances the signature well.
Negative.
Best Resources.

Signature 08.

Positive.
Negative.
- The background it very distracting, instead of being drawn to the girl, the contrast, brightness and crispness of the of the BG is stronger than the soft fuzziness of the girls. The font is also very busy.
Best Resources.

Signature 09

Positive.
Negative.
- Font seems a little too fancy for the sig. Background is pretty distracting from the image of the Senshi, who are also a bit too small for the overall signature.
- The font is a bit hard to read and the picture is too small, it just seems swallowed up by the textures.
- I didn't like the font used or the background used for this signature, it didn't really fit well with the photo. Something more pastel-y would have worked ^_^
- I love the picture, but I don't like the background that was used. The color in the text and the text stood out nicely, but I really didn't like the background added to the image.
- It has a lot of textures and you can barely see the girl's faces there. The color text could have been another one since the chosen color makes it hard to read.
Best Resources.

Signature 10

Positive.
+ Colors blend very well together and do not block view of Outer Senshi and SM in the background, font and other textures match the scene very well and seems to perfectly express the elegance of the Outers.
+ I like the use of brushes and text. I also like the cropping and the lighting.
Negative.
- I'm not sure the cropping really works and I couldn't really read the font either.
- I didn't liked the font used for the text, it was nice and went with the graphic, but I couldn't read it.
Best Resources.
* This signature used their textures and resources to their advantage. I would have liked to seen the signature a bit lighter but it's fantastic!