Liked
004.

+ I love the textures used for the backdrop. It ties in with the sadness of the quote and really gives the signature that extra touch.
+ Simplicity speaks very loudly at times.  The graphic is the key to making the quote stand out.

001.

+ Easy to read, the colors set the mood for the quote.  Love the font, romantic yet masculine.
+The choice of text in this one is quite fitting. It almost makes it look like it was written out as a love letter which fits perfectly with the quote. I also like the backdrop and the brushes used. It's a very nice, soft background.

003.

+ I love how everything in this signature reminds us of Venus. Her color, her symbol, and then the placement of the text is just interesting and creative.
+ I loved the simplicity of this one and the text used and colors.

002.

+ I love the colors of the text in this one as well as the font. I also liked the background chosen for it.

005.

+ Beautiful colors all around! Love the sky image, the texture, and even the font chosen is pretty.

Dislike
006.

- I feel like the text and the red moons are random. It would have helped if the word "Earth" matched with the other bigger words. Plus the text for "nothing" is a little jarring.
- I disliked it because of the text and the background. They didn't feel like they fit to me.
- I didn't realize the design through the middle of the signature was a word.  I was having trouble understand the quote.
- I know you want to highlight the important words, but making us read the bottom sentence up and down as well as left to right is a bit confusing at times. Interesting effect on the word 'nothing', though!

005.

- The text is a little difficult to read in the middle of the signature.

002.

- The text being all over the place sort of makes it hard to read the sentence as a whole because you're not sure where to start and where to go next.

004.

- I didn't like the background for this one.

003.

- I feel like this one could have been expanded more. It seems a little simple although it is a nice signature. I think the artist could have added a little more flare considering the character their talking about.

Most Creative
004.

* I don't know where they found the pattern for the background but its perfect for a signature that hints at something sad. It gives it that lonely and broken feeling and I just love it.

001.

* It flows together very well.
* I loved the uses of different text to make a point on the words it was used for. I loved the background and the stencil on it.

005.

* I just love that there's a lot of resources used here. It's not only a text-based signature, but it also has textures and effective use of colors as well as the background image. Despite the lack of actual pictures it feels like you maximized its potential and still made a beautiful work of art.