Alright, This doesn't have an actual poll, more like a think tank and a suggestion thread.


Weekly seems to be too often for people. However I left this one open longer, and only had 3 people turn things in. Also, voting was a problem, we had a lot of ties and since no one voted it was at a stand still.


I'm proposing 2 weeks at a time. And each week, a chance for people to petition for it to go longer by 3 days. Also opening the voting to the public each round.


Thoughts? Suggestions?

I agree with this

I agree with it to

I personally think the weekly challenges should be monthly challenges.

I like every two weeks. I agree with voting being made open to the public too. I think that way it can showcase what's going on in the Guild and bring in more members, while also drawing in people to vote.

i think that is waaaay to long. This is meant to make graphics a daily part of your life, 4 weeks is pretty excessive in my opinion. Working with deadlines can help you learn how to find inspriation and "make it work" ^^

I would be doing more weekly challenges and posting....school consumes my life so much, but I do like the idea of challenges. I am actually in a computer graphics class and just learned photoshop a bit this week.

2 weeks sounds good and opening it up the the public sounds good too

Bi-weekly and public voting seems like a good solution!

Yes and yes! Weekly on top of so many other challenges/contests constantly going on in the forum is just too much in my opinion

Every two weeks sounds pretty good, there are some weeks when I want to compete but can't because I have too much going on.  But, on the other hand, there are weeks when I feel like it is taking forever! Personally, I prefer the every week system, but if the two week system would bring in more entries, then I'm all for it.

Holding the challenges bi-weekly sounds good.

PockyPants wrote:

Yes and yes! Weekly on top of so many other challenges/contests constantly going on in the forum is just too much in my opinion

there does seem to be a lot right now. We've got LSMS, the contests for the different events (like Senshi Bdays), and I shall be starting up the Artist's Contest very soon too. Perhaps every other week would work best. I keep wanting to enter but all of a sudden the week is over and I'm like "wtf did the time go?" XD

you know.. with many of the graphic communties i've been on, two weeks for a challenge are the norm. i think it's a great idea to extend the challenges to a two week limit.

we should do lims too!!!!! since i missed out the 100 icon challenge. .__.

I think there was already a 100 icon challenge, so with the last sigmaker and weekly challenges(which has icons), i think we were worried about over loading.

Every two weeks sound slike a good idea.  I have trouble getting graphics out because my computer time is limited until my husband gets his own computer.  He's been using mine for work.