Alright guys, who do you think is the best of the Sailor Animamates? Who is the worst? Explain!

My favorite would be either Heavy Metal Papillon or Aluminum Siren!

HMP is one of my favorites because, even though she was only present for a little while, she's always seemed to be the most powerful (even though Phi and Chi are actually the strongest) because of her connection to the souls of the dead and how immense her power could really be. The whole concept with her hunting souls and turning them into butterflies is actually quite clever and even lovely to me. Plus she's got the prettiest and most elaborate outfit out of everyone! Do you know how many times I've colored pictures of her in the past? ♥

Aluminum Siren is my other favorite because of how scatterbrained and ditzy she can be. She's always made me laugh and I think Usagi and her would make a great friends if AS wasn't evil! I also love how suddenly she can switch to being serious and freak out if she's in battle. Not to mention her outfit is something I seriously want to own even if it's a little PG13+....ahaha... ^^;;

My least favorite would be Phi/Chi as a pair. They killed so many of my favorite senshi and while the concept of them being Star Seed gardners is okay, I think they should have had a more interesting job. I also was annoyed that they weren't just one person. There's been a few evil twins before in the series (Lethe and Mnemoysne, and yes even though they're technically one person, Cyrprine and Ptilol count in my mind too). It's a little old to me that this idea was used again

Spoiler Alert

Lethe and Mnemosyne weren't evil. They were just afraid and thought that working for Galaxia could lead them to a chance to end the war once and for all. They were actually real Sailor Soldiers that joined Galaxia in hopes of getting a chance to end all war.

Now, I'd love to say that Lethe and Mnemosyne were my favorites, but considering the fact that they weren't Sailor Animamates and were instead real Sailor Soldiers, I can't. So I guess I'll pick Sailor Phi and Sailor Chi, since they killed the Starlights, who I hate very much. But yeah, I do love Lethe and Mnemosyne not only because of their roles in the manga, but also because they were probably developed the most and the best out of all of Shadow Galactica.

I do not care for the Animates very much in the manga because, well, as you said, they killed off so many of the Senshi. :/ That is just too painful.

In the anime, however, they were fine. Sailor Aluminum Siren is just my favorite. I love everything about her. She is such an adorable and flaky character but is all polite and follows Japanese customs as if they are important to her. And I really liked her seiyuu a lot. I thought that she did a perfect job of portraying the character.

Sailor Tin Nyanko broke my heart when she found half herself and realized the evil that she was doing. It was so saddening to see her try to fight against herself and then be killed off by Galaxia.

As for my least favorite? Probably Sailor Iron Mouse because she was all cutesy and kind of a bother to me. :/

Tin Nyanko was a really nicely developed character in my opinion. The whole thing about her inner struggle to try and be good near the end was a nice touch! Galaxia really wasn't very forgiving was she? :C She should have at least given her the chance to become pure and then fight her, seeing that she was internally fighting herself at that point

Chi and Phi aren't part of the Sailor Animamates guys, they're the Star Gardeners (the seven animamates are Mouse, Seiren, Crow, Fox, Kerokko, Nyanko and Papillon, the name is probably coming from "animal" and "animate")

My favourite: Seiren and Fox
Least favourite, probably Nyanko, nothing against her, I just like the others better

Houyou no Senshi wrote:

Chi and Phi aren't part of the Sailor Animamates guys, they're the Star Gardeners (the seven animamates are Mouse, Seiren, Crow, Fox, Kerokko, Nyanko and Papillon, the name is probably coming from "animal" and "animate")

My favourite: Seiren and Fox
Least favourite, probably Nyanko, nothing against her, I just like the others better

Damn it, haha. I couldn't pick Lethe and Mnemosyne because they're Sailor Soldiers, and now I can't pick Sailor Phi and Chi? Oh man, I guess this leaves me with Papillon

Oh wait....I guess you're right x_x I always confused Phi and Chi with Animamates! Well then that makes my least favorite Iron Mouse then because she just didn't seem that great, to be honest. I felt she just was a generic kind of villain, not much to her....I don't know //shrugs

For me it's also Aluminium Siren - her diary is just so adorable

Well, in the anime, they're all stupid and horrible at picking targets, so I don't like any of them.
I never got that far in the manga...

In the manga, they are kinda generic monsters of the day.